Masterpiece Cakeshop Conflict Redux

Masterpiece Cakeshop Conflict Redux

Those who imagined the Supreme Court decided in favor of Jack Phillips and his wedding cake business may have been drinking the Kool Aid if they thought the issue was going to quiet down anytime soon.

I predicted there would be more trouble for Jack, and it didn’t take long. New discrimination charges were filed against him, this time for refusing to bake a cake to celebrate a transgender transition. Those who want to celebrate gender transitions have every right to do so. But in a free society, why are small business people like Jack made the subject of such obvious harassment? Whether or not you or I would bake the cake, Jack has a right to his beliefs. He is not going out of his way to harm anyone.

There is a simple solution to this particular arena of battle between sexual liberty and religion. Simple, albeit unlikely. The problem lies in the underlying discrimination statutes. You see, small employers are legally entitled to discriminate. That’s right. Under Federal law, if you have less than 15 employees, you can legally tell someone whose race, religion or gender you don’t like that they can’t work for you. And under many state laws, the exemption applies to employers of less than five workers. But there is no similar exemption for small business when it comes to serving the public. Public accommodations laws broadly restrict businesses from refusing to serve customers on all the usual bases. The original purpose was to eliminate restrictions on race discrimination against African Americans who were excluded from most hotels, restaurants and the like. Public accommodations laws are important. But in today’s economy, there is no reason they need to be wielded as a sword against small businesses.

Case in point. There is a prominent case that arose in Washington State involving a law requiring pharmacists to both stock and dispense the “morning after” pill, a form of birth control. A pharmacy challenged the law as a form of religious discrimination, and ultimately lost. But in years of litigation, the state never found a single customer who had been unable to obtain the needed pill in a timely manner due to a pharmacist having a religious objection. My point is that in today’s economy, people can obtain the needed goods and services broadly, and are rarely disadvantaged by religious conscience claims.

But the law does not reflect that reality, instead disfavoring religious conscience claims, and regarding them with suspicion. In most cases, they will lose. By the way, it was a conservative Supreme Court that did this – by way of Justice Scalia’s 1990 decision in the infamous “peyote” case. So those who believe a conservative Supreme Court will better protect religious freedom are surely misguided.

Now, even a small business exception would not help Jack Phillips. His bakery employed more than five people. So the battle rages, and eventually, the Supreme Court may actually decide the underlying issue. Or perhaps Congress will act first, and craft a truce between sexual liberty and religious liberty.

I’m not holding my breath. But from where I sit, in a free society, we all get to define our own identity, and live by our own values and beliefs. The rub is that we don’t get to impose these on others, or use these beliefs to harm others. It is much easier to state the principle than to apply it in difficult conflict situations. So the culture war continues to rage, and I remain a non-combatant, wishing both sides would take a chill pill. Instead of looking for conflicts, like bringing a new case against Jack Phillips, let people live in peace, leave them alone. If conflicts arise naturally, we figure them out. We don’t need to create a time of trouble before the time. And Y’shua taught us in the Sermon on the Mount not to be anxious about tomorrow – each day has enough trouble of its own. There are legitimate areas of conflict between sexual liberty and religious liberty. But both sides in the culture war make matters worse by looking for trouble, and creating conflict. So I leave you with this: “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called the children of God.”

Alan J. Reinach, Esq., serves as Executive Director and Chief Counsel of the Church State Council, the religious freedom education, advocacy and legal services ministry of SDA’s in southwestern United States.

Picture originally found here

Related Articles

More From Prose

A Fishy Tale

I received a fish tank in my teens. I’m not sure if it was for my birthday or some other…
A Fishy Tale

Trying to Fit

I have been very lucky in that there is a lot of flexibility regarding what I can wear to work.
Trying to Fit
Photo of sheep inspiring reflection on the verse

The Lord is My Shepherd

I remember going on a Shabbat drive with family through the beautiful countryside somewhere in…
The Lord is My Shepherd

Havdalah

I’ve written in a previous article about Reuben Caplin (Ruby), my voice teacher and choral…
Havdalah
Noah's Bubbe

Noah's Bubbe

Kathleen Moore is an RN, a mental health counselor, specializing in the field of grief and…
Noah's Bubbe
Cream Cheese vs Peanut Butter

Cream Cheese vs Peanut Butter

Since I was a kid I loved cream cheese. I also loved peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. My…
Cream Cheese vs Peanut Butter

Cruise Control

I am used to traveling pretty far distances for work but one thing I never really used while…
Cruise Control

Conquering the Monster of Fear

Years ago the picture on the front of a church bulletin depicted a lovely bird perched on the…
Conquering the Monster of Fear

Silly George

My neighbor asked if I could watch her cats while she was away. One of her cats, George, had to…
Silly George

Angels on Duty

Donna’s husband suddenly left his family without looking back.
Angels on Duty

Corrie Ten Boom

The Nazis arrested Corrie and the rest of the ten Boom family in Febuary 1944. Ten days after…
Corrie Ten Boom

Satan Popped the Watermelon

It was Friday and I was busy cleaning and getting ready for Sabbath as usual. I tossed out an…
Satan Popped the Watermelon

East 105th Street

I grew up on East 105th Street, in Cleveland, Ohio. I went to Gracemont Elementary school. My…
East 105th Street

Publish the Menu module to "offcanvas" position. Here you can publish other modules as well.
Learn More.


donation